Gas Vs Charcoal Grills - Which is Best to Buy in 2023

The spring season has arrived, meaning the grilling season has finally arrived. Many innovative grilling techniques are present to enjoy outdoor cooking, like state-of-the-art smokers with electric capabilities and wood pellet grills. However, every barbeque enthusiast is having debates while cooking about which one is the best gas vs charcoal grill.

Charcoal grills produce more smoke, and gas grills are much more convenient. Which one is best for you? To answer this very frequently asked question, I have explored the grills and described the fuel source that will produce a delicious taste.

What Is A Charcoal Grill?

A charcoal grill is a domestic grill that uses charcoal briquettes or lump charcoal as a fuel source for cooking. The fuel of the charcoal grill is present beneath the grill grates, and the lighter fluid and wood chips start up the coals.

Many people consider the charcoal grilling method to be an authentic grilling method. Grills can be categorized by their size and shape, which means you can choose according to your preferences. Therefore, charcoal grills are top-rated worldwide.

The fact is that char-grilling gives your food an unbelievable taste. You may face little problems while starting it and controlling the heat. However, charcoal grilling might prove less efficient and slow than gas grilling.

How Does A Charcoal Grill Work?

If you want to enjoy the summer season with outdoor cooking, then read the following instructions carefully.

Lift your cooking grates and fill the grill reservoir with hardwood. Then, spread the wood thick on the surface and keep the bag near because there will be a need for it.
Wear the protective grills and light your woods using a chimney starter or a match.
Keep the gloves worn, and when the coals become ignited, then stir them by using a fire poker. Refrain from stirring the coals that are ignited.
Adjust the air vents in such a way that the upper vents remain closed while the bottom vent remains closed. It helps the burning process to slow down and keeps the flavored smoke in the grill.
Place your food on the grill and close the lid, but ensure that the bottom vents remain open and the top vents are closed. If needed, open the top vents to adjust the temperature.
After completing the process, close all the vents and lids. It will help to stop further combustion.

What Is A Gas Grill?

Gas grills are the most famous and are manufactured on an enormous scale worldwide. The grills are available in a large variety and are very easy to use. There are many features included in a gas grill.

The use of liquid propane is more common than the use of natural gas. Usually, they run on gas, but you can also use liquid propane. You might have to pay a little effort while purchasing propane, but natural gas is almost available at every house.

Though both gas and propane have their benefits and downs, so it depends upon your needs and what type of fuel you will use. Converting gas grills to LP grills is easy with a conversion kit.

Natural gas has many advantages over LP, like it is cheaper than LP, there is no need for refilling till the gas is connected, and it burns cleaner. If you want to stick to the gas grill and have access to gas, it will give you many benefits.

How Does A Gas Grill Work?

Before starting a gas grill, connect LP/Fuel supply to your gas grill.

Open the fuel source so that it can move freely in the grill.
You can adjust the temperature by using those valves where the gas enters.
To distribute the smoke evenly around the food, you can also place briquettes over the flames. All of you know that the food cooks indirectly in the pellet grills.
Many gas grills have a couple of burners surrounded by holes. After lighting up the starter, After igniting the starter, a spark ignites the gas, and then the flames will come out of the pits. You can use the valves to control the temperature.
The grill hood is lowered to move the air inside and reach the desired temperature. It is possible to cook them both with and without a grill hood.

Pros And Cons Of Charcoal Vs Gas Grill

Pros Of Charcoal Grill

There are some benefits of the charcoal grill. Impressive cooking performance, convenience, and versatility are some benefits of a charcoal grill, So let’s discuss some other features of it.

Heat: It is the most significant advantage of a charcoal grill that can never be ignored. A charcoal grill can reach 500 degrees Fahrenheit with the hood down, and some can reach 700 degrees Fahrenheit. But the gas grill cannot come close to that figure. The few that can match this temperature level use infrared heating zones and high-performance commercial burners.
Flavor: When the liquid drips from other ingredients and meat, they become vapors on touching the coals. These vapors condense the food and sear it, and some mists infuse into the food. These drops vaporize too rapidly as the charcoal is very hot.
Price: The charcoal grills are usually of simple designs. They are made up of fewer parts and thus are less complex. That’s why they are less expensive. Besides, charcoal grills will last longer. A dry piece of charcoal will be stored longer than the gas. So, with this grill, you can earn a handsome profit.
Fuel: In most parts of your country, charcoal is readily and inexpensive. Charcoal is much more convenient for many people.

Cons Of Charcoal Grill

As we know, everything has some flaws, so is the case with charcoal grills. Let’s have a look at its disadvantages of the charcoal grill are the following:

Starting The Grill: It is more challenging to create a charcoal grill as compared to a gas grill. But, make things simple by using some equipment such as a chimney starter.
Controlling Heat: Charcoal grills are easy to maintain once they’re fired up, but controlling the heat can take some getting used to. Gas grills have more reasonable temperature control than charcoal grills. Closing the vents will decrease the temperature while opening vents will increase the temperature.
Topping Up: You need to add more coals for the longer grilling sessions. But, with the gas grill, a canister of gas will last for more than seven cooking sessions.
Safety: Charcoal grills are not safe like gas grills, so try to keep them away from pets, children, and combustible buildings. Unlike any other burning fuel, it is straightforward to shut off the gas.

Pros Of Gas Grill

Price: They are usually much more inexpensive as compared to charcoal grills. A high-quality gas grill can be found at a meager price, and with a bit of extra work, it can be turned into a high-tech grill.
Temperatures: Anyone can achieve a high temperature in the gas grill with a little effort. When it comes to steak, grill marks are essential if you want to get the coveted ones.
Speed: You can save a lot of time by grilling on a gas grill instead of a charcoal grill. The reason is they use different cooking methods. A gas grill quickly reaches a high temperature so that it will cook your food rapidly.
Cleanliness: Gas grills are easy to clean. It is effortless to clean your gas grill.
Accessorizing: Due to its popularity, grills can be customized with all accessories. You can add a smoke box, a sear burner, a griddle pan, and so on.

Cons Of Gas Grill

Flavor: A gas grill will produce no taste in your meat because the gas is odorless. It does not mean that it imparts terrible flavor to your food, but it neither gives sour flavor nor good flavor to the food.
Safety: Cooking with gas is always dangerous. It is imperative to read the rules and regulations for cooking when connected to the gas line because there is a risk of gas spreading or explosion.
Heat Retention: Gas grills cannot maintain a constant temperature due to ventilation requirements. Despite having all the necessary smoking accessories, you should refrain from using them as a smoker.
Temperature Control: It may be very challenging to control a gas grill’s temperature. While you turn the valves, you will lose a lot of your time. You should have to use the grill in each type of grill, but it is a process that must be repeated.

Comparison Table

Characteristic	Gas Grill	Charcoal Grill
Ease of use	Required little instructions	Experience required
Cool-down time	5-10 minutes	10 minutes
Temperature control	Easy to maintain	Requires constant attention
Smoke	Difficult to trap smoke	Designed to trap smoke
Price	More expensive	More affordable
Maintenance	Check propane tank and gas line	Replenish coals
Cleanup	Scrubbing grill grates	Ash disposable
Flavor	Natural flavor	Smoky flavor
Heat-up time	10 minutes	30 minutes

Features Comparison Between Gas & Charcoal Grill

Gas Grill Vs Charcoal Grill Price Range

The standard gas grills are available in the $129-$299, while high-tech gas grills are more than $1000. Although you can find gas grills with as many bells and whistles as you want, you can always find great deals on sturdy ones.

A standard Weber Kettle grill is $ 150, while a high-quality charcoal grill costs more than $1000. On the other end, a low-quality charcoal grill is available for $25. Some grills cost less than $15. They are very low-weight and biodegradable.

Gas Grill Vs Charcoal Grill Taste

A smoker may get the smokiness of a charcoal grill. However, the smoke does not matter for gas grilling lovers. Gas can quickly cook delicate foods such as vegetables, fruit, fish, and chicken breast, and those foods that taste can be overwhelmed by the smoke.

The charcoal grill is guaranteed for the smoky taste of your chicken, pork chops, steaks, and other grilled foods. As long as you place wood chips strategically, you can use a charcoal grill as a smoker as well.

Gas Grill vs Charcoal grill Fuel Cost

It will cost $30 to fill a 20-pound gas grill that will last about 20 hours. It means the grilling process costs $1.5 per hour. A large chimney starter can hold six quarts of charcoal. Sixx quarts of good-quality charcoal will cost about $5.50. At the same time, normal-quality charcoal will cost about $4.40/.

Gas Grill Vs Charcoal Grill Temperature Range

The cheaper gas grill models cannot achieve the temperature required for searing, i.e. 600 degrees Fahrenheit. However, the gas grills will work efficiently with the lower BTUs. The lump charcoal burns hotter than the briquettes, so the grill’s temperature depends upon the charcoal you are using.

A charcoal grill filled with charcoal can easily reach 700 degrees Fahrenheit. Many pitmasters have argued that the taste achieved at 200 degrees Fahrenheit cannot be obtained at any other temperature.

Gas Grill Vs Charcoal Grill Maintenance

You need to refill the propane tanks, replace the briquettes, and check the fuel lines and gas connections for a gas grill. You will also need to keep the drip tray, ignitor collector box, and burners clean. The easiest way to minimize its upkeep is to cover it when unused.

Depending upon tear and wear, you should have to replace the grill grates after every year or when required. There are only options to replace once you would not have a gas or charcoal grill.

Gas Grill Vs Charcoal Grill Health

Gas-powered appliances contain fewer carcinogens than charcoal-burning devices, which produce charred food. The footprint of the gas grill is also too small, about 1/3 of the charcoal grill. So, the winner of gas vs charcoal grill carcinogens is the gas grill.

Frequently Asked Questions

Gas grills have the most negligible effect on the environment than charcoal grills. They are considered environment-friendly grills. Propene produces the least amount of carbon, which is about 5.60. Propane is not only environmentally friendly but also is much more efficient.

The food cooked on a gas grill contains fewer carcinogenic compounds than that prepared on charcoal grills, so gas grills are safer for your health. Besides, the carbon footprint of the charcoal grill is larger than the gas grill, and that’s why they produce more carcinogens.

Some barbeque enthusiasts like charcoal grills as they add a smoky flavor to your food. Such people claim that the taste of the grilled food is because of the charcoal grill. While others say that the gas grill is the winner because it does not change the flavor of the food and keeps it natural.

You cannot use charcoal in most gas grills. They are designed to handle heat generated by burners, not heat generated by burning charcoal. It is a fundamental distinction to make and may save your grill.

Final Words

While both types of grills have advantages, let’s do an overall comparison between charcoal and gas grills. Comparing the fuel source, we can conclude that charcoal grill may require more effort to produce food but this task is also easier to complete.

When it comes to convenience, a gas grill offers you less effort for all the tasks because you do not need to attend the grilling when cooking. If you want convenience with delicious food, choosing a gas grill can be a perfect choice.

Gas Grill Vs Charcoal Grill