Butcher Paper Vs Foil

Wrapping meat is a pro trick when you are halfway through smoking meat. You might be curious why you need to do it as a newbie, right?

By wrapping the meat, you ensure the moisture gets locked when you enter the next half of cooking, as it helps you remove juicy and tender meat. 

Not only does the wrapping method add softness to your meat, but it also accelerates the cooking time. Regarding what you should use to cover up the meat, there are two options: butcher paper and aluminum foil.

People equally use both of them, but they have some differences. If you want to learn more, keep reading.

Why Should You Wrap Meat When Smoking?

Wrapping the meat while smoking has the following benefits: 

Makes Meat Tender

Wrapping your meat while smoking will make it tender. It is because the moisture trapped in the wrapper stays there until you consume it. It also prevents the drying of the outside surface of the meat. The wrapping process helps keep the inside moist and juicy, making it more tender after it is cooked.


Prevent It From Drying

The wrapping process also prevents your meat from drying while cooking. When you wrap your meat, you do not need to add additional moisture or sauce as it has already been wrapped with one layer of paper or foil. This way, you can cook your meat without adding any extra liquid or sauce that might cause a soggy texture to your meal.

Accelerate The Cooking Time

Wrapping your meat will help you speed up its cooking time. When the outside layer is not exposed to heat during cooking, it will take less time for all parts of the meat to be warmed up and cooked thoroughly. You can apply this technique to prepare a meal ahead of time and have everything ready before starting the cooking process itself. 

Difference Between Aluminum Foil And Butcher Paper

To understand the differences between aluminum foil and butcher paper lets deeply know about both of them in detail:

Butcher Paper

Butcher paper has a thin layer of paper on both sides, which works like a bridge between the heat source and smoked food. Recycled newsprint is usually used to make butcher paper. This makes it affordable as well as environmentally friendly. You can use butcher paper in large and small quantities of meat or fish for smoking at home.



  • Great for wrapping meats, fish, and poultry 
  • Not too thick or thin 
  • Easy to write on with a pencil or pen 
  • You can use it for preserving meats and fish in the freezer


  • It can tear easily when handled too roughly 
  • Not suitable for other food items

Aluminum Foil

Aluminum foil is an excellent choice for cooking because it does not stick to the food. In addition, aluminum foil does not burn quickly and can be used multiple times for different dishes. It is also easy to clean up after using this material for cooking purposes. But it is more challenging to get a pleasantly even temperature with aluminum foil, and you have to be careful not to burn your food.



  • Durable and Reliable 
  • An excellent conductor of heat, so it increases cooking time 
  • Non-toxic like other metals 
  • Versatile 
  • Inexpensive


  • It can be flimsy, so you need to be careful when using it 
  • Thickness can make it hard for you to cut accordingly.

Butcher Paper Vs Foil For Ribs

For better taste and flavor, you should cook ribs low and slow. Therefore, it demands a combination of indirect heat, smoke, and time. Ribs are one of those foods best simmered, so it is essential to ensure your smoker is set up correctly. 

A good smoker should have a water pan or chamber for the smoker box to sit in, which will help keep the temperature throughout the meat as you smoke it. You can also use an offset smoker, a regular grill that sits on top of another grill with a chimney. 

It is convenient because you do not have to build a separate fire pit for smoking ribs like a traditional barbecue pit. Many people use butcher paper to wrap around their ribs during cooking because it provides insulation and keeps them from drying out too much while being cooked at low temperatures. 

Foil works well, too, because it is porous. However, it can get pretty thick after sitting in the sun for long periods. I suggest you choose butcher paper for cooking ribs over aluminum foil as aluminum gets heated up too quickly, which will ruin your low and slow cooking method.


Butcher Paper Vs Foil For Smoking

Smoking meat is a fun and delicious way to add flavor to your meals. If you love smoking but do not want to spend much money on it, you might consider using butcher paper instead of foil. 

Butcher paper is a flexible material that you can use for wrapping foods before smoking them. People often use it in the kitchen when cooking fish or poultry because it seals in moisture and keeps food moist during cooking.

On the other hand, fuel is typically used for cooking meats and vegetables by covering them with aluminum foil. From this, it is clear that butcher paper is a much better option for smoking than aluminum foil. 

Butcher Paper Or Foil Brisket

For beef brisket, I can say both butcher paper and aluminum foil are good options, so it all comes down to your personal preferences:

How To Wrap Beef Brisket In Butcher Paper?

Follow these instructions to wrap the brisket in butcher paper:

  1. You will need to start by cleaning the brisket. Never use paper towels because they will leave a bad taste in your meat, mainly if you use them to wrap your beef brisket. Instead, use a clean cloth or paper towels. Make sure they are thoroughly dry before covering the beef brisket. Then, add spices and rub them into the meat.
  2. After that, place the brisket on a flat surface and cover it with butcher paper on all sides except for one side (the top). Make sure that there is no extra butcher paper hanging off any part of the meat so that nothing sticks out when it is finished cooking and served.
  3. Next, place another piece of butcher paper on top of the first. So, you have two layers trapping all the spices inside while keeping them away from direct contact with your food until you serve it up. It will ensure that nothing sticks to your food when you finally eat it.

How To Wrap Beef Brisket In Aluminum Foil?

If you wrap beef brisket incorrectly, it will be dry, so follow these steps:

  • Wash your hands thoroughly before handling your brisket. Use soap and warm water if needed to clean your hands thoroughly. You do not want any food particles on your hands when you start wrapping the meat.
  • Cut off both ends of the aluminum foil so that it is at least 6″ longer than your beef brisket in thickness, with an extra inch for overlap.
  • On top of one foil sheet, lay another and fold it over on itself. So there are two layers, each about 6″ long by 4″ wide by 1/4″ thick. 
  • Fold both pieces in a way that they overlap by 1″ on both ends and have no creases. It will help keep everything in place during cooking and protect your hands from burns if there is any contact with the hot pan or grill surface.

How To Wrap Pork Shoulder In Butcher Paper?

Pork shoulder is the most versatile cut of meat you can use for making slow-cooker recipes. It is an excellent cut for fall and winter meals because it does. It does not dry out as much as other cuts. Butcher paper is lovely for ensuring that your pork stays moist and tender. The following steps are beneficial to you in wrapping pork shoulder in butcher paper:

Eliminate The Excess Fat

Remove the fat layer from the pork shoulder. You can do this using a meat tenderizer or a sharp knife. Do not try to eliminate too much fat, or it will be hard to wrap around the meat.

Start Wrapping

Lay out your butcher paper on top of your cutting board and place the pork shoulder down on top of it. Place another layer of butcher paper over the meat so that you have two pieces of butcher paper covering your meat. After that, place another layer of butcher paper on top of that piece, so now you have four layers covering your pork shoulder (two pieces on each side).

Finish It Up

Now you are going to start wrapping. Start at one end and fold up about halfway along your pork shoulder until you reach where you started at the other end of your pork shoulder (the point where you began wrapping). Then, fold back over to where you started folding up first instead of folding back. 

What Is A Texas Crutch?

What Is A Texas Crutch

As we all know, many recipes for barbecuing beef brisket across the United States, including Texas Crutch. It is a prominent way to barbecue beef brisket by wrapping it inside aluminum foil. Pitmasters prefer this BBQ method because it gives the meat enough texture and flavor.

Is Butcher Paper The Same As Baking Paper?

Butcher Paper and Baking Paper are both forms of paper that are used for wrapping food products, but they have different purposes. Butcher Paper is commonly used in the meat industry and is made from wood pulp and has a brown or grayish-brown color. People typically use it to wrap cured meats such as bacon, ham, sausages, and more. Moreover, the butcher paper comes in rolls that can be cut down to size or folded according to your needs.

Baking Paper is another type of paper that is used in kitchens and bakeries. Baking paper is made from natural or recycled materials and comes in many colors, including white, yellow, green, blue, red, orange, and more. It is often used for wrapping cakes or pastries during the baking process so they do not dry out too fast while waiting on their final product.

Final Words

I would say I go for butcher paper most of the time. But this does not mean that foil is not good, or you can ignore it. Both butcher paper and aluminum foil are reasonable options for wrapping meat, but they work better for specific meats and cuts, so keep this thing in your mind. Covering your meat with them can ensure that the juices get locked. It moistens, tenderizes, and helps cook faster.

Similar Posts